I'm not sure what I was expecting from this volume on a post-war
Washington riddled with former military men and spies and current
diplomats and newspaper owners and journalists, but what I ended up
reading was akin to a gossip column. First, there are entirely too many
characters introduced too quickly. It's easy enough to keep the main
players in mind: Kennan, the Alsop brothers, and a few others, but the
rest become background noise as they're mentioned every now and then
with the author taking for granted that the reader should have memorized
the index and all the names presented therein. Secondly, relevant
context is often missing. Just one example will have to suffice. The
author brings up the creation of NATO and that Kennan favored a more
limited organization consisting of the US, Britain, and Canada. That's
it. Why did Kennan favor such an organization? Why didn't he consider
France or West Germany in such an organization? What/who were the other
contenders for NATO? Nothing. Three mere sentences on an organization
that to this day continues to impact international politics and
policies. But what gets almost 2 whole pages of mention? The 'heinous
outrage' of a house Joe Alsop created in Georgetown that resulted in a
municipal ordinance against such future monstrosities. As a result,
it's really hard to believe this is a book written by an academic as it
reads like a tabloid full of lurid details about ivy league universities
with their student societies and drinking bouts and unadulterated
rumors full of inept guesswork and misplaced emotions. Then again,
perhaps that's what the US Cold War policy was all about.
No comments:
Post a Comment