Brian Glyn Williams offers an in-depth and engaging account of Chechen
history via their regular need to fight those attempting to subdue them
and control their land. The accounts begin with Russian incursions into
Chechen territories, the opposition raised and its inevitable defeat by
a force that can readily engage in prolonged attacks and sieges and can
rely on a large pool of manpower against the infinitely smaller number
of Chechens and their allies who can, at best, take to the mountains and
continue a form of guerrilla warfare that leans on ambushes. This
resistance continues in the face of the Russian Revolution and
eventually during the Second World War, for numerous reasons, the
Chechen people are accused of collaboration and, along with other
minorities in and around the Caucasus, are deported wholesale to Central
Asia, where tens of thousands die and suffer for the next decade until
in the 1950s Khrushchev's administration allows their return (although
in truth Khrushchev had little say in the matter as many simply took
their belongings and returned home). Then, the eventual break up of the
Soviet Union leads to this minor internal Russian region to demand
independence and take up the fight against Russian forces when they
resist any such move (fearing a domino effect could ensue). After
losing too many troops the Russians begin to negotiate with a variety of
Chechen personalities and eventually a very precarious calm settles on
the region only to be interrupted by a series of bombings within Russia
and a renewal of hostilities against Chechnya.
All of the above
is what the majority of this text covers, the Boston bombings are given a
chapter, the last, and to be honest that chapter is somewhat the least
interesting (not the author's fault). The strengths of this book are
that you have an academic with a wide knowledge of both the Chechen
people and territory and their place within the history of the Russian
Empire, the Soviet Union and the Russian Federation today. Furthermore,
he makes a good case for why Chechens and their struggle against Russia
should not be conflated with Al Qaeda and other terrorist
organizations. At the same time there are some weaknesses readily
evident within the pages of this text. First off, there is a distinct
bias toward the Chechen side. In part it's understandable but it also
translates to at times an omission of the Russian side and at other
times a distinct impression that Russians can do no right. The
Russian/Soviet side is not represented to the same degree as the
Chechens and it also appears that not enough condemnation is being
offered for some of the more drastic actions taken by Chechen fighters.
Just because they might treat hostages well doesn't mean they're not
guilty of perpetrating terrorist acts against civilians. Overall, this
is an excellent but at times biased introduction to the history of
Chechen resistance and its evolution, especially in the post-Cold War
period. It really shows how complex the situation is in and around the
Middle East/Central Asia and how we need to have a grasp on the
situation there to figure out how best to fight terrorism (international
and regional) and avoid creating a worse situation than already exists.
No comments:
Post a Comment