Father Patrick Desbois is partly responsible for our understanding
of "The Holocaust by Bullets," the mass murder of millions of Jews
throughout Eastern Europe that is often overshadowed by the assembly line mass
murder of Jews and other "undesirables" in German death camps.
In his first publication on the subject, Desbois took an original
approach to the topic by aiming to interview adolescent bystanders who could
still recall how and where the local Jewish population was murdered by the
invading Germans and their collaborators.
"In Broad Daylight"
takes that initial research a step further as Desbois and his team have
continued to gather information through interviews and presents the minutia that has often been overlooked or simply never considered by
researchers or academics. We have many accounts from German concentration and
death camps by survivors and perpetrators, but Jews murdered by the millions in
mass graves no longer have a voice. Those who were lucky enough to
survive can only offer accounts from their limited perspective, but Desbois is
interested in the minute details that were needed for mass murder to become an almost
acceptable everyday phenomenon.
He looks at a typical mass
murder site starting from the night before, when locals were conscripted to
help transport Jews to their final destination and when German forces and their
collaborators would begin arriving inevitably leading to a night that finally
saw the last vestiges of human decency disappear as Jews were beaten and raped
before their eventual executions in the early morning hours. Aside from
speaking to those who only witnessed German aktions Desbois's
team also initiates discussions and interviews with those who participated in
cooking the food the Germans ate while on break from executing Jews, those who dug
the mass graves, and numerous others who one day lived with their Jewish
friends and neighbors and the next found themselves drawn to either watching
their death, including hearing their cries and screams, or in some way
participating in the German aktion itself.
This is a haunting and deeply
disturbing text. For many, simply reading a list of sites where German
mass murders took place throughout Eastern Europe leaves them unable to grasp what those on the ground witnessed and experienced as their
everyday lives were torn apart by an invading army and a genocidal occupation
policy. Therefore, this is a volume best read slowly and methodically so that
readers can contemplate what humanity is capable of all too easily when
presented with a specific set of circumstances as those with a superiority
complex decide human life is cheap and disposable. This is a study that offers an important contribution to
our understanding of how the Holocaust by bullets unfolded and presents in a new light the vital role
played by the local population in the mass murder of East European Jewry.
1 comment:
This sounds like a book which makes a valuable contribution. It reminds of Omer Bartov's first book which brought home to me that the young, regular German Army soldiers had been indoctrinated since adolescence, and spontaneously began murdering Jews when they got the opportunity. The process in this book sounds much more organized, but still it is not on an industrial scale, and presumably the recordkeeping was not up to the best German standards, and it is probably difficult to estimate how many people were murdered in this fashion. No I would not put it past the Germans to have somebody standing with a clipboard carefully recording how many people are being shot in the back of the head. Interested to know if the findings in this book change the estimated total number of Jews murdered by the Nazi regime or not.
Post a Comment